Tag: judicial appointments
-

Lewis Graham: Judicial Ideology and Supreme Court Appointments
Appointing Supreme Court Justices When a vacancy arises on the UK Supreme Court (UKSC), how is it filled? And what considerations are taken into account when deciding on which qualified candidate to appoint? The answer to the first question is easy enough to answer: the Lord Chancellor convenes an ad hoc selection commission, which must…
-

David Stott: Ministerial Influence in Judicial Appointments – Taking Back Control?
Not since the Blair era has a government been so committed to a significant programme of constitutional reform as the Johnson government, but with very different objectives. The Blair government sought to modernise the constitution and, through the Constitutional Reform Act 2005, to formalise a separation of powers in respect of the judges by (i)…
-
Dimitrios Kyriazis: Does EU law preclude national constitutional provisions under which the executive plays a role in the appointment of members of the judiciary?
‘The accumulation of all powers, legislative, executive, and judiciary, in the same hands, whether of one, a few, or many, and whether hereditary, self-appointed, or elective, may justly be pronounced the very definition of tyranny.’ Madison’s famous proclamation in the Federalist Papers (No 47) forms the theoretical basis underpinning the doctrine of the separation of…
-

Byron Karemba: A ‘Brave’ Appointment? On Professor Burrows’ Appointment to the Supreme Court
Introduction The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom (UKSC) is a much more visible and accessible institution than the Appellate Committee of the House of Lords. Through delivering extra-curial speeches on matters of general public importance beyond technical points of law and engagement in an array of ‘outreach initiatives’, individual Justices of the Court are…
-

Richard Clayton: Transforming Judicial Selection Procedures: Privy Council Changes Trinidad High Court Selection Procedure
In A-G of Trinidad and Tobago v Maharaj the High Court and Court of Appeal in Trinidad decided that the Judicial and Legal Services Commission (which appoints High Court judges) should comprise just judges and ex judges. However, in an important new judgment delivered on 11 February 2019 the Privy Council reversed the Trinidad courts…
-

Rachel Jones: Increasing Judicial Diversity – A Constitutional Imperative?
Tuesday marked the launch of JUSTICE’s Working Party report, Increasing judicial diversity. The Lord Chief Justice, Lord Thomas, spoke at the event, alongside Chair of the Working Party and leading public law barrister Nathalie Lieven QC. She urged those present to take up the report’s vision, and outlined recommendations for systemic, long-term change. Attendees included…
-

Jan van Zyl Smit: Judicial appointments in the Commonwealth: Is India bucking the trend?
In recent years many Commonwealth states have adopted, or at least debated, reforms to their legal frameworks for the appointment of judges. The stated objectives of such reforms include strengthening the independence of the judiciary, improving its racial and gender diversity, and fostering or enhancing public confidence in the courts. One of the most common…
-

Comment on India: Chintan Chandrachud: India’s Deceptive Constitution
Every written constitution is supplemented by important unwritten principles: the constitutional law of all nations (whether or not they have a codified constitution) consists of some combination of the written and unwritten. Judges interpret the abstract language of written constitutions and speak where the text remains silent. As a codified constitution grows older, it forms…
-

Greg Weeks: Comment on Australia: A history of judicial disrespect and the current “crisis” in the Queensland judiciary
It has never been a universal requirement that a candidate for senior judicial office is either well respected or even well liked, by the public at large or by his or her judicial colleagues. For example, Lord Hewart was a political appointee who had no judicial experience upon becoming Lord Chief Justice. He has been…
-
Colm O’Cinneide and Kate Malleson: Are quotas for judicial appointments lawful under EU law?
In April 2014 Sadiq Khan, Shadow Secretary of State for Justice, asked Karon Monaghan QC and Geoffrey Bindman QC to review the options for a future Labour Government to improve diversity in the judiciary. On November 6th their report, entitled ‘Judicial Diversity: Accelerating change’, was published. Starting from the premise that ‘[t]he near absence of…