Tag: Court of Session
-

Jamie McGowan: The Nobile Officium and Public Law: An Undertapped Resource?
Joanna Cherry KC MP has suggested (here and in parliament), somewhat indirectly, that the nobile officium of the Court of Session might, insofar as it “exists to give remedies where there would otherwise be none”, be exercised to limit the effect of the provisions of the Safety of Rwanda (Asylum and Immigration) Bill 2023-24. Notably,…
-

Jeff King: Miller/Cherry and Remedies for Ultra Vires Delegated Legislation
The issue of remedies for any finding that the 2019 prorogation of the UK Parliament is unlawful is presently under discussion in pleadings in the joined appeals of Miller No.2 and Joanna Cherry MP (and others) in the Supreme Court. Essentially, the question concerns what must occur if the minister’s advice is found unlawful, and…
-

Stephen Tierney: Prorogation and the Courts: A Question of Sovereignty
The request made by the Privy Council that the Queen prorogue Parliament was a clumsy and inappropriate attempt to shorten the time available for parliamentary scrutiny of the Brexit process. That much seems clear from papers submitted to the Court of Session in Cherry. It is therefore no surprise that the Inner House was receptive…
-

Yossi Nehushtan: Prorogation and Justiciability
The question of justiciability lies at the heart of the judicial response to the legal challenges that were brought against the Prime Minister’s administrative decision to advise the Queen to prorogue Parliament in Miller 2 and Cherry. The judicial reluctance to exercise judicial review regarding the administrative decision to advise the Queen to prorogue Parliament…
-

Dean Knight: Reasoning Through Challenges to Prorogation: Cherry and Miller (No 2)
The challenges to the prime minister’s request to the Queen to prorogue Parliament in the face of the fast approaching Brexit deadline have many fascinating dimensions (Cherry v Advocate General [2019] CSIH 49 and R (Miller) v Prime Minister [2019] EWHC 2381 (Miller (No 2)). The question of justiciability has been at the forefront. And…
-

Hayley J. Hooper: Keeping the Lights On: Contrasting Miller v Prime Minister and Cherry v The Advocate General
If the phrase “may you live in interesting times” actually has its roots in a curse, then, we constitutional lawyers are indeed cursed. The specific nature of the curse is the malleable nature of constitutional controls designed to protect our institutions from the whims of executive action. At the time of writing, Britain is set…
-

Alison Young: Prorogation, Politics and the Principle of Legality
Constitutional lawyers often point to key cases as milestones in public law. Recently, the Supreme Court decision in Privacy International joined the ranks of leading public law cases, adding to the cases discussing ouster clauses and the extent to which courts can review decisions of inferior courts and tribunals in Anisminic and Cart. As Privacy…
-

Timothy Endicott: Don’t Panic
The brilliant accident of our form of constitutionalism is not just that the executive came to be accountable to an assembly. It is that the assembly came to be responsible for the executive –for its membership, its policy, its operation, everything. Prorogation, in particular, concerns the operation of the proceedings of Parliament, and it is…
-

Alan Greene: Miller 2, Non-justiciability and the Danger of Legal Black Holes
In R (Miller) and Others v The Prime Minister (hereinafter Miller No.2), the High Court of England and Wales found that the decision of the Prime Minister to advise the Queen to prorogue parliament was non-justiciable. In doing so, the judgment reveals the propensity of the judiciary to be much more protective of its own…
-

Ben Christman: An Unholy Resurrection in the Court of Session
Relaxed standing tests for judicial review are critical to maintain the rule of law. Too restrictive, and the executive may act unlawfully – safe in the knowledge that judicial oversight is precluded by the courts’ doors being closed to the public-spirited litigant. In certain circumstances, restrictive standing tests can leave illegal executive action essentially unchallengeable.…