Tag: constitutional review
-
Douglas Edlin: Will Britain Have a Marbury?
Marbury v Madison is the most famous judicial decision in US history, written by the most important judge in US history. According to the traditional understanding, Chief Justice John Marshall brilliantly side-stepped a looming political clash between former President John Adams and newly elected President Thomas Jefferson. In doing so, Marshall declined the additional power Congress attempted…
-
Derek O’Brien: The Basic Structure Doctrine and the Courts of the Commonwealth Caribbean
The basic structure doctrine, as first expounded by the Indian Supreme Court in the early 1970s in Kesavanand Bharati v Kerala (A.I.R. 1973 SC 1461), asserts that the law-making powers of a legislature are not unlimited in as much as they do not extend to altering the ‘basic structure’ of the constitution. Some 40 years…
-
Dawn Oliver: Parliamentary Sovereignty in Comparative Perspective
I Parliamentary sovereignty in other countries In this post I defend the absence of judicial strike down powers in the UK by exploring the ways in which other countries besides the UK manage to function well as liberal democracies without courts enjoying strike down powers, and looking at some of the negative aspects of the…
-
Se-shauna Wheatle: The Residual Powers of the Court
There has, justifiably, been much debate about the implications of the judgments of the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom in R (Jackson) v Attorney General [2005] UKHL 56, [2006] AC 262 and AXA General Insurance Ltd v The Scottish Ministers [2011] UKSC 46, [2011] 3 WLR 871. What is perhaps the most constitutionally significant…
-
Mike Gordon: What is the Point of Exceptional Circumstances Review?
A great deal of the controversy surrounding the recent case of Axa General Insurance Ltd v Lord Advocate [2011] UKSC 46, already much discussed on this blog, stems from the notion of ‘exceptional circumstances review’. The Supreme Court’s decision that it has the authority as a matter of common law to reject Acts of the…
-
Bradley W. Miller: Proportionality and Legislative Purpose
In conducting constitutional review with a proportionality test, much depends on the how the purpose of the challenged legislation is characterized by the reviewing court. It is a commonplace that the loftier the purpose attributed to the legislation, the more difficult it will be to judge that legislation to be disproportionate at the balancing stage. …